A Serial Killer Dismembered Women in This Long Island Home. Now It Costs $800K.
The house at 1492 Garden Street in East Meadow, Long Island is back on the market. No fresh coat of paint changes what happened inside between 1989 and 1993.
The listing price is $799,999. The property last sold in 2011 for $322,000. That is a 148% jump in 14 years, priced right alongside every other normal home on the block.
The problem is, this is not a normal home on the block.
The House and the Man Behind the Headline
Joel Rifkin lived here with his mother and sister in what looked, from the outside, like a perfectly ordinary suburban split-level. Four bedrooms. Built in 1951. Quiet neighborhood.
Between 1989 and 1993, he strangled at least 9 women and confessed to 17 murders total, primarily targeting sex workers across New York. Several of those murders and dismemberments took place inside this house and in the garage.
When police arrested him in June 1993 after a car chase in Wantagh, they found a chainsaw, traces of human flesh, and blood in the garage.
Lead investigator Lt. Eugene Corcoran of the New York State Police described Rifkin’s upstairs bedroom as “filthy” and “like a hoarder’s room.” Rifkin has been serving 203 years to life since 1994. He is 67 now, sitting in Clinton Correctional Facility, and going nowhere.
From $322,000 in 2011 to $799,999 Today
When Rifkin’s mother passed away and his sister inherited the home, it was listed at $424,500. Multiple price cuts followed. At least two buyers reportedly made offers then backed out after learning the history.
It finally sold in 2011 for $322,000, well below ask. The buyers, whose identity was never disclosed, were fully aware of the history.
‘The listing agent at the time, Greg Berkowitz of Laffey Real Estate, said the buyers “realized they were getting a devalued price” and that the value proposition ultimately “overcame the history.”
Now it is back. And this time, the seller is asking $799,999, right in line with comparable East Meadow homes currently listed between $795K and $869K. There is no visible discount being offered for the history.
You can read the current listing details over at Realtor.com’s coverage of the property.
What New York Law Actually Says Buyers Can Ask
Here is the part most people covering this story are skipping entirely.
Under New York Real Property Law Section 443-a, a homicide or felony crime at a property is not considered a material defect. The seller and the listing agent are not legally required to bring it up on their own.
The burden is on the buyer to ask. If a buyer submits a written inquiry asking about crimes or deaths on the property, the seller must answer truthfully. Most buyers assume this disclosure is automatic. In New York, it is not.
This same dynamic plays out quietly across high-profile listings. Take Melanie Griffith’s LA retreat, recently relisted at $5.8 million after a stunning renovation, a reminder that every relisted property comes with a history most buyers never think to ask about.
If you follow stories where real estate and overlooked history intersect, there is a WhatsApp channel worth checking. Good place to stay ahead of these stories before the news cycle catches up.
Why This Matters
This is not just a true crime curiosity. There is real money behind the question.
According to Finder.com’s analysis based on University of Technology Sydney research, homicides cause an estimated $7.5 billion drop in total U.S. housing market value annually.
Stigmatized property expert Randall Bell notes homes sold shortly after a murder typically take a 15 to 25% hit in value within the first three years.
The Rifkin home has had over 30 years of distance from the crimes. Time does soften stigma in real estate. But “softened” and “gone” are two very different things.
The current $799,999 ask suggests the seller believes the stigma has faded enough to command full market price. It is a bold position. And it raises the same questions that surround any property with weight behind it.
Dakota Johnson listed her $6 million West Hollywood home right after Fifty Shades made her famous, and buyers were fascinated more by the story than the square footage. The same pull exists here, just with a much darker backstory.
Even in cases like the Richard Simmons LA estate that took a $580K price cut weeks after being relisted, the market eventually decides what a story is worth. Rifkin’s house will be no different.
Key Takeaways
- The home at 1492 Garden Street, East Meadow is listed at $799,999
- Joel Rifkin was convicted of 9 murders and confessed to 17, several committed at this address between 1989 and 1993
- The home last sold in 2011 for $322,000, a 148% price increase over 14 years
- New York law does NOT require automatic disclosure of murder at a property
- Buyers must submit a written inquiry to get a truthful answer about the home’s history
- Stigmatized homes historically take a 15 to 25% value hit within the first three years of a crime
- Rifkin, now 67, remains at Clinton Correctional Facility on a 203-year sentence
Would you buy a house with a history like this if the price and neighborhood were right? Or is this the kind of past that no discount can fix? Drop your take in the comments below.
Wrapping Up
The sale of this home is, on paper, a straightforward listing. Price, address, square footage, done.
But if you know what happened inside those walls, it feels like something else entirely. A story that never really closed, just went quiet for a while.
If this kind of story is your thing, Build Like New covers celebrity real estate, true crime property history, and the human side of big transactions regularly. Worth bookmarking if you want more than just the headline.
For more stories like this in real time, follow Build Like New on X (Twitter) and join the conversation over on the Facebook community. That is where these stories get discussed as they break.
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only. All details are based on publicly available records and reports at the time of publication.
