Alec Baldwin Re-Lists His Massive Hamptons Estate for $21 Million

I’ll be honest with you — some houses come and go in the Hamptons, but this one refuses to fade from the conversation. Every time Alec Baldwin puts his Amagansett farmhouse back on the market, it sparks the same question: why hasn’t this place sold yet… and why does it keep coming back?

When I looked at the new $21 million listing, the first thing that struck me wasn’t the price. It was the timing. Baldwin has tried for years to find the right buyer for this 10,000-square-foot estate, and the property has seen multiple price swings — from way up at $29M, down to $18.99M in early 2024, and now bumped back up again. That alone tells me this isn’t just a “celebrity home for sale” headline. There’s a deeper story here about timing, sentiment, and what high-end buyers actually want.

And honestly, if you’ve followed Hamptons real estate even casually, you know how rare a 10-acre spread is. That alone should’ve made this estate move quickly. But the fact that it didn’t is exactly what makes this new listing interesting — it opens up a lot of questions about the market, the property, and the psychology of luxury buyers.

Before we get into all that, I want you to picture this: an old farmhouse Alec bought back in 1995, updated over decades, featured on his family’s TLC show, sitting quietly next to a nature preserve. It’s not your typical shiny Hamptons mansion — this place has history, quirks, and memories baked into the walls. And whenever a home carries that much personal weight, the sale becomes more than a transaction.

So let’s start here: the house is back on the market, priced strong, and positioned for the kind of buyer who’s not scrolling listings for fun — someone who actually wants a retreat with character, land, and a bit of celebrity history attached.

What do you think matters more in a home like this — the celebrity name, or the land and legacy?

Inside the Estate: What Makes This Farmhouse a $21M Listing

When I went through the latest details of the listing — especially the breakdown TMZ shared — one thing became obvious instantly: this place wasn’t built to impress in a loud, flashy way. It’s the kind of home that grows on you the more you look, not the more you scroll.

TMZ confirmed the basics: 10,000 square feet, 7 bedrooms, 10 acres of land, and a layout that feels more like a lived-in retreat than a showpiece mansion. And honestly, that’s a big part of the appeal. You’re not buying some sterile “celebrity mansion.” You’re stepping into a property that feels like someone actually lived in it, hosted family dinners, raised kids, and tucked memories into each corner.

The amenities are exactly what you’d expect from a long-time celebrity home — a movie theater, a wine-tasting room, a wood-paneled library, and an outdoor pool and spa. But here’s the part I keep coming back to: the balconies and screened patios overlooking the surrounding nature preserve. If you’re someone who cares about privacy, or you crave quiet weekends with no noise but birds and wind, that view alone is half the value.

Homes like this don’t sell to people who want perfect edges. They sell to people who want space, soul, and maybe even a story.

If you’re interested in more unique celebrity pools, check out how Liberace’s legendary LA mansion with its piano-shaped pool made headlines

A Scenic Backdrop With History and Sentimental Weight

The more I dig into this property, the more it stops feeling like a simple real-estate listing and starts feeling like a personal chapter Alec Baldwin is finally ready to close.

He bought the place in 1995, long before Instagram tours and drone shots dictated how a Hamptons home should look. And he didn’t buy it as a flip — he raised a family here, filmed scenes for his TLC show “The Baldwins”, and renovated it through different eras of his life.

What I love about this estate is that almost everything ties back to the setting. That nature preserve behind the home isn’t just a pretty view — it’s the same backdrop Baldwin used in his video pitch back in early 2024, when he practically walked viewers through his personal attachment to the property.

There was something unpolished but honest about that video… and honestly, it made the house feel less like a trophy and more like a lived-in sanctuary.

Some homes sell themselves through marble floors and glass walls. This one sells itself through the feeling it gives you when the camera pans to the trees.

Price History: The Roller Coaster No One Talks About

If you’ve watched the Hamptons market as long as I have, you know when a price chart tells a story — and this one definitely does.

This farmhouse has been listed, relisted, pulled off, and re-introduced so many times that the price history looks like a heartbeat monitor. It started high around $29 million, dropped dramatically to $18.99 million in 2024 when nothing moved, then shot back up to $21 million for this new push.

And honestly, that bump says a lot.

A seller typically raises the price only if they’re confident about two things:

1. The market sentiment feels better than before
2. The previous low price didn’t attract the right buyer anyway

In other words, Baldwin isn’t chasing whoever shows up — he’s holding out for someone who understands what a legacy property on 10 acres in Amagansett is actually worth.

Properties with history and acreage don’t get valued the same way as modern builds with infinity pools. Their worth comes from scarcity and story, not just square footage.

What’s Really Stopping This Place From Selling?

This is the section most people skip… but it’s the one that reveals the real truth.

From everything I’ve analyzed — listing history, buyer behavior, agent commentary — the issue isn’t the house. It’s the buyer pool.

Here’s what I mean:

• Houses above $20M need extremely specific buyers.
• Those buyers often want either ultra-modern builds or oceanfront lots.
• A 10-acre, historic-style estate appeals to a different type of homeowner — someone who values land and privacy over trends.
• Celebrity homes attract massive attention but fewer serious offers. People love to look but hesitate to buy.

There’s also the emotional factor. You can feel Baldwin’s attachment to the home. Buyers can too. And believe it or not, that sometimes makes people hesitate — no one wants to overpay for someone else’s memories or underpay and feel like they’re taking advantage.

So when people ask, “Why hasn’t it sold?” the answer is simple: It’s waiting for someone who wants more than just a big house.

The New Listing Agent and the Shift in Strategy

This round, the listing is being handled by Scott Bradley of Saunders & Associates, and I don’t think that’s a small detail.

Bradley is known for selling homes with character — not just the shiny, modern Hamptons builds but the ones with backstories, acreage, and heritage. And that gives this listing a new angle.

When I look at how previous attempts were marketed, something was always missing: a clear narrative. The home was treated like a product, not a legacy property.

Bradley’s approach is different.
Expect the marketing to feel more like:

• “Here’s an estate with history,”
• “Here’s a rare 10-acre retreat,”
• “Here’s a home you grow into, not one you pose in.”

That shift matters — because homes like this don’t sell with drone shots alone. They sell when the right buyer sees their future in the photos.

From Diane Keaton’s Pinterest-inspired home back on the market to Richard Simmons’ Hollywood Hills estate with a price slash, our site covers the most fascinating celebrity properties.

Why the House Still Hasn’t Sold After All These Years?

When you look at this place on paper — 10 acres, a massive custom build, every luxury amenity you can think of — it’s hard to imagine it sitting on the market this long.

But the truth is, ultra-high-end homes in the Hamptons often move slowly. Not because they aren’t valuable, but because the buyer pool is tiny.

People shopping in the $20 million range usually want one of two things: Turnkey modern, or historic with a story.

Alec’s place is both — but not fully either. It’s timeless, warm, lived-in, and a little eccentric. It’s the kind of home you fall in love with emotionally, not logically. And homes like that need the right buyer… someone who cares about privacy, land, character, and a bit of Hollywood history.

That buyer just hasn’t walked in yet. But it doesn’t mean the house is any less remarkable.

The Emotional Side: Alec’s 30-Year Relationship With This Property

I keep thinking about the fact that Alec bought this home back in 1995.

That’s almost three decades of memories — long before the headlines, long before social media followed every move celebrities make.

For him, this wasn’t a trophy home. It was where he raised family. Where he hid from chaos. Where he built a version of life that felt slow and grounded.

You can feel that kind of history in the listing photos — the library, the porches, the tucked-away corners.
There’s a depth to the place that newer Hamptons builds just don’t have.

And honestly, you can sense why he keeps relisting it instead of giving up. Selling isn’t just a transaction for him — it’s a goodbye.

If you want to get quick updates on rare luxury homes like this one, there’s a WhatsApp group that shares listings and news in real time — it’s a handy way to stay in the loop.

What This Listing Says About the Hamptons Luxury Market Right Now

A price bump back to $21 million tells you one thing: confidence.

Even with higher rates, the Hamptons luxury segment is still moving — especially for properties with land, privacy, and character. That’s exactly what this home offers.

Buyers today aren’t just hunting square footage.
They want lifestyle, storytelling, and emotional value.

This property checks every box:

• Massive acreage
• Nature preserve views
• Unique architecture
• Personal history
• A-list provenance

And when a home has a strong narrative, it almost always finds its buyer — even if it takes longer than expected

Final Thoughts

Every time I look at this listing, I get the same feeling: this isn’t just another celebrity home hitting the

market.
It’s a real piece of someone’s life, shaped by decades of family and memory, sitting quietly on a stretch of Amagansett that almost never comes up for sale.

If anything, the renewed $21 million listing feels like a bet — not just on the market, but on the idea that someone out there will walk in and instantly understand what this estate really is.

If you had the budget, would you go for a place with history like this… or would you choose a modern build with clean lines and no emotional baggage?

Curious about more iconic celebrity homes and luxury estates? Check out our Real Estate & Homeownership section for the latest listings and stories.

Disclaimer: This article is based on publicly available information and local reports. Details of the listing may change, and readers should verify current pricing and property status with the listing agent or official sources.