Aubrey Plaza Removes $6.5 Million LA Home From Market
I’ve been following celebrity real estate for years, and sometimes, the story behind a listing is as compelling as the home itself. Take Aubrey Plaza, for example. Just three months after putting her $6.5 million Los Feliz home on the market, she’s pulled it off—leaving everyone wondering why.
This isn’t just another luxury property story. This is the house where her husband, Jeff Baena, tragically passed away. It was a space filled with memories, grief, and life-changing moments. Plaza listed the home in September, eight months after Baena’s death, and now, as of December 23, the home is off the market. Whether she plans to relist it remains unknown.
As I look at this story, I see more than price tags and square footage. I see someone navigating personal loss in the public eye, balancing grief with life, career, and the spotlight. And that’s what makes this story resonate beyond the headlines.
Timeline of Events: From Listing to Delisting
If you’re trying to make sense of this, the timeline actually tells a lot. Plaza listed the Los Feliz home in September 2025, about eight months after her husband, Jeff Baena, tragically passed away. The property, a four-bedroom, 5.5-bathroom Mediterranean-style house, immediately drew attention—not just for its luxury, but because of the very personal story behind it.
Then, on December 23, 2025, the listing disappeared. It was quietly delisted, with no official statement about whether Plaza plans to relist it in the coming months. When I see this, I can’t help but think about how public grief can influence personal decisions. This wasn’t just a real estate move—it was a deeply human choice.
Even if you’re not following celebrity real estate closely, the timeline frames the story: listed, delisted, uncertain future—and it’s the emotional context that makes it resonate.
The Home: Architectural and Luxury Features
Now let’s talk about the home itself, because it’s more than just numbers on a page. Built in 1928, this Mediterranean-style dwelling sits in the coveted Los Feliz Oaks neighborhood. According to Realtor, the property was purchased off-market in October 2022 for $4.7 million, and before that, it last sold in 2017 for $3.6 million.
Inside, the house is a mix of historic charm and modern luxury. You’ll find a screening room, wine cellar, pool, oversized steam room, and a state-of-the-art sound system. Arched windows and doorways create a sense of flow, while natural light fills every room. There are pops of color, too—a pink couch in the living area, funky yellow-and-green tile in the bathroom, and the primary bathroom painted a soft pale rose, which feels very Aubrey.
Outside, multiple living areas are designed for dining, lounging, and entertaining, shaded by a canopy of trees. There’s also a grassy lawn and a swimming pool that blends beautifully with the natural surroundings. The home’s listing described it as a “private sanctuary, brought back to life with care, style, and enduring character.”
Similar to Richard Simmons’ Hollywood Hills mansion selling for $5.9 million, Plaza’s Los Feliz home shows how celebrity properties combine privacy, luxury, and character in ways that attract high-profile buyers.
Why Plaza Listed the Home in the First Place?
Understanding why Plaza listed the house isn’t simple, because it’s intertwined with grief. Jeff Baena’s passing left her navigating a profound loss, and putting the home on the market was likely part of that journey.
Around the same time, she was promoting her new movie, “Honey Don’t!”, attending red carpet events, and giving interviews—including a conversation with Amy Poehler where she opened up about her grief.
She even compared her feelings to the 2025 sci-fi movie “The Gorge”, saying that grief sometimes feels like a chasm filled with monsters—inescapable and constant, yet something she sometimes wants to face and sometimes avoid.
So when I look at the September listing, I don’t see a celebrity flipping a house. I see someone trying to reclaim space and autonomy while navigating unimaginable personal pain.
Just like Gene Simmons re-listed his Beverly Hills home after a $1 million price drop, celebrity homes often go through strategic listing adjustments that balance market demand with personal timing.
Why the Delisting Might Have Happened?
Here’s where most articles fall short—they report the delisting but don’t analyze it. From what I can see, there are several reasons that might have led to this U-turn:
- Emotional and privacy considerations: Living in the home after such a loss is intensely personal. The listing might have felt premature.
- Market perspective: Luxury homes, especially celebrity ones, are tricky. The timing, buyer pool, and price can all influence whether it makes sense to sell immediately.
- Practical timing: Plaza’s media tour and public engagements around the same period could have delayed any concrete selling plans.
By thinking like a realtor or someone who’s watched the LA luxury market, it’s clear that delisting doesn’t mean a permanent “no.” It’s a pause, a reflection, or just a deeply human reaction to life circumstances.
If you like keeping a close eye on celebrity property moves, there’s a WhatsApp channel that shares daily updates on the most talked-about homes—you might find some interesting insights there.
Inside the Public and Media Spotlight
Of course, the story didn’t stay private for long. Every red carpet, interview, and social post became part of the narrative. Fans, media outlets, and social media communities have all speculated on why Plaza delisted, with conversations ranging from empathy for her grief to curiosity about celebrity real estate.
Even small details—like her choice of pink accents in the home—became talking points, showing that people notice not just the property, but the person behind it.
When you see this kind of public attention, you realize how intertwined personal and professional lives can become, especially for someone in the public eye.
Just like Kylie Jenner listed her concrete LA mansion at $48 million, celebrity home listings often intertwine personal timing, public attention, and market strategy, which can make each sale as much about emotion as money.
What’s Next? Possible Future Plans
Now here’s where curiosity really kicks in: will Plaza relist the home, or is this a permanent decision? No one knows for sure, and that’s okay. In the luxury LA market, especially for celebrity homes, a delisting often isn’t final. It can be a strategic pause or just a personal choice.
From a market perspective, homes in Los Feliz Oaks tend to sit longer than average when the owner is high-profile. Realtors say celebrity listings often undergo cycles of interest, media attention, and timing adjustments before a sale actually happens. Plaza could very well relist when she feels ready, or she might keep it as a private sanctuary.
The takeaway? Life circumstances and emotion can influence decisions far more than price tags. And as a reader, it reminds me that behind every “for sale” sign, there’s a human story.
Final Thoughts
One thing I want to emphasize: this story is delicate. It involves grief, privacy, and personal loss. While it’s tempting to speculate, it’s important to separate what’s public fact from assumptions.
Respecting that human side is what makes reporting on celebrity real estate meaningful. It’s not just a $6.5 million home—it’s someone’s lived experience, memories, and sanctuary.
That’s the angle I focus on, because it’s what gives the story real depth and value.
For more inside scoops on celebrity homes and luxury real estate, you can follow updates on X and join the conversation on our Facebook group.
Disclaimer: The information in this article is based on publicly available sources and verified reports. All personal details are treated with sensitivity and respect. This content is for informational purposes only and does not speculate on private decisions.
