Amy Schumer Sells Brooklyn Townhouse for $11M, Takes Loss

I still remember seeing that iconic Brooklyn Heights townhouse in photos and thinking, “Wow, this place has a story.” And now, Amy Schumer has officially sold it—for $11 million, a noticeable drop from the $12.3 million she and Chris Fischer paid just a few years ago. If you’ve been following celebrity real estate, you know that price swings like this aren’t just about the market—they often tell a story about timing, lifestyle changes, and yes, personal transitions.

What makes this sale even more compelling is the context: Amy and Chris are heading for divorce after seven years together. Yet amid all that, they’re keeping the focus on raising their son. The house, once listed at $14 million and later reduced to nearly $12.8 million, is now under contract, and the buyer is linked to Michael Saltzman, a producer known for The Boys and Murphy Brown.

In this article, I’ll take you inside the townhouse itself, explore why the sale didn’t hit the original asking price, and give you a peek at what makes Brooklyn Heights one of New York’s most desirable neighborhoods. Whether you’re a real estate enthusiast or just curious about Amy Schumer’s life, there’s more here than a simple price tag.

Sale Details — Price, Timeline, and Context

I want to start by getting the numbers straight because that’s what everyone notices first. Amy Schumer’s Brooklyn Heights townhouse first hit the market at $14 million in March, then was relisted for around $12.8 million before finally going under contract at $11 million. That’s roughly $1.25 million less than the $12.3 million she and Chris Fischer paid back in 2022.

It’s important to note that this isn’t just a simple market move. The sale coincides with Amy and Chris heading toward a divorce after seven years together. In a statement on social media, Amy shared that they “love each other very much and will continue to focus on raising our son,” which adds a personal layer to the story behind the price.

The buyer, according to the Robb Report, is an LLC tied to Michael Saltzman, a producer known for shows like The Boys, Murphy Brown, and The Pink Panther. Knowing who’s buying adds another dimension—you’re not just looking at a number, you’re seeing the continued cultural relevance of this historic property.

Similar to Amy’s townhouse, Alec Baldwin recently put his Hamptons home back on the market at $21 million, highlighting how celebrity real estate often reflects personal life changes.

The Iconic Townhouse — Historical and Architectural Highlights

If you’ve ever walked through Brooklyn Heights, you know the neighborhood has a charm all its own. Amy’s townhouse is no exception. Built in the early 1800s, it’s a Federal-style home with a 26-foot-wide brick facade and a distinctive mansard roof.

This house also comes with a bit of Hollywood history—it was featured as the Castorini family home in the 1987 Oscar-winning film Moonstruck, starring Cher and Nicolas Cage. Beyond the cultural significance, the townhouse offers roughly 5,500 square feet spread across five levels, including four (or possibly five) bedrooms and four baths.

Natural light floods the home through 30 windows, highlighting the exposed beam ceilings and wide-plank floors. Outside, the backyard, landscaped by Michael Van Valkenburgh, currently hosts a turf play area but could easily be converted into private, gated parking if the new owner chooses.

The level of interior renovation in Amy’s townhouse is reminiscent of Kaia Gerber’s revamped Manhattan apartment, where every detail was designed to blend modern luxury with classic charm.

Interior Features & Luxuries

Now, let’s get into the part that really makes you pause. The townhouse has a pair of fireside parlors separated by large pocketing doors—a design choice that feels both grand and intimate. One of the bedrooms has been converted into a library that opens directly to the kitchen.

And the kitchen itself is a dream: vintage wood cabinetry, a marble-topped island, Gaggenau and Lacanche appliances, a butler’s pantry with a zinc bar sink, and a cozy breakfast nook. It’s functional, but also perfect for entertaining.

The primary suite occupies the entire third floor. Imagine a corner bedroom warmed by a fireplace, connected dressing and sitting rooms, a private office, and a marble bath that features a second fireplace, dual sinks, a clawfoot soaking tub, and a glass-encased shower.

Elsewhere, three more bedrooms share a penny-tiled bath, and there’s a wine cellar and gym tucked into the lower levels.

If you enjoy getting real-time updates on iconic homes like this one, there’s a WhatsApp channel that curates luxury property news and market insights—perfect for quick, bite-sized updates.

Why the Sale Didn’t Hit Original Asking Price?

You might be wondering: why sell for less than the purchase price? A few things are at play. First, luxury real estate in New York has been cooling slightly, with buyers becoming more selective on high-end properties.

Second, personal circumstances often accelerate a sale, and in this case, Amy and Chris’s separation likely influenced the timeline.

It’s also worth noting that luxury homes, even iconic ones, sometimes take longer to find the right buyer. The original $14 million listing might have been optimistic for the current market, while the final $11 million sale reflects both timing and negotiation dynamics.

Celebrity Real Estate Context

This sale isn’t happening in isolation. Celebrity townhouses in New York have a pattern: sometimes they sell for far above market value, other times below.

Amy’s sale fits into a broader trend of high-profile homeowners recalibrating their investments, whether for lifestyle shifts, financial reasons, or personal circumstances.

Looking at similar properties, we can see that not all celebrity homes retain the glamour price tag long-term. By understanding these patterns, you get a glimpse not just into the Schumers’ lives, but also the economics of New York luxury real estate.

Brooklyn Heights Neighborhood Insights

If you’ve never spent time in Brooklyn Heights, let me paint a picture. It’s one of New York City’s most historic neighborhoods, lined with brownstones, tree-lined streets, and a skyline view that feels almost cinematic.

This area commands premium prices for a reason. Homes here aren’t just about square footage; they’re about history, charm, and location. Amy’s townhouse is a perfect example: a mix of classic architecture, modern amenities, and that famous Moonstruck connection.

Knowing the neighborhood helps you understand why this house was priced where it was—and why someone like Michael Saltzman would see value in it.

Just as Holly Madison’s Los Angeles home showcased the appeal of a high-profile location, Brooklyn Heights remains a neighborhood where history and prestige drive property value.

Buyer and Future Outlook

Speaking of Michael Saltzman, the buyer’s LLC now holds the keys. While we don’t know every detail about their plans, the house’s versatility makes it appealing. The backyard could stay a play area, become a garden, or even a gated parking space.

Looking forward, this sale reflects a subtle trend: high-profile properties may fluctuate in value depending on timing, personal circumstances, and market dynamics.

If you’re tracking celebrity homes or thinking about investing in luxury NYC real estate, it’s a reminder that patience and context matter just as much as curb appeal.

Curious about more celebrity home sales and luxury real estate stories? Visit our Celebrity Homes
section to explore the latest listings and insider updates.

Disclaimer: All information in this article is based on publicly available sources and reported sale details. Prices and buyer details are accurate to the best of our knowledge at the time of publication. This article is for informational purposes and does not constitute financial or investment advice.