JJ Redick Puts Brooklyn Penthouse Back on the Market for $6.2 Million
I’m watching this one close: Lakers coach JJ Redick has just relisted his Dumbo penthouse for $6.2 million, and that price tells a story you won’t get from the short celebrity blurbs. I’ve pulled the listing details and the timeline: a 3,000-square-foot duplex atop a seven-story ODA conversion, four bedrooms, four-and-a-half baths, and roughly 2,500 square feet of landscaped terraces that wrap both levels. The agent handling it is Rachel Greenstein of Compass — a detail that signals a top-tier marketing push, not a casual sale.
You should also note the price history: bought by Redick and his wife Chelsea Kilgore in 2017 for just over $6 million, first listed at about $8.5 million in 2021, trimmed to $7 million in 2022, and now back on the market at $6.2 million.
That sequence is more than numbers — it’s a market signal. Either the seller is resetting expectations to attract serious buyers, or the market (and lifestyle priorities) have nudged the property into a new pricing band.
There’s another layer: Redick isn’t just any seller. He’s a 41-year-old former Duke standout and 15-season NBA veteran who moved into media and now coaches the Lakers (2024). When a high-profile owner with East-to-West lifestyle ties lists in New York while coaching in LA, you have to read personal timing into the move — family needs, coast-to-coast logistics, or simply wanting a home that fits a full-time family life rather than a pied-à-terre.
Bottom line: this is a relist with history, heft, and context. If you’re reading for the headline — it’s a celebrity listing. If you’re reading to understand value and intent, watch the price trajectory, the agent choice, and the timing with Redick’s career. Want me to pull comparable Dumbo penthouses and a quick market snapshot next?
Inside JJ Redick’s Dumbo Penthouse — A Designer’s Masterpiece
When you look at the photos shared by Robb Report, the first thing that hits you isn’t the square footage — it’s the quiet precision of the design. This isn’t one of those “modern gray box” penthouses. The space feels lived-in, layered, and genuinely personal.
Redick and his wife, Chelsea Kilgore, bought the duplex back in 2017 and turned it into a European-inspired retreat with the help of designer Michael Aiduss — the same renovation that Architectural Digest later featured.
I love how they handled the structure: white-oak herringbone floors that catch natural light from both terraces, brass fixtures that give warmth, and soft French moldings that tame the industrial bones of the old warehouse.
Even the kitchen tells a story — Aegean blue lacquer, bronze trim, and a slab of Calacatta marble so clean it almost reflects the terrace greenery outside. You don’t see many NBA players invest this kind of taste into design, and that’s what makes it stand out.
What really draws me in is the outdoor connection. Both levels open onto landscaped terraces designed with Gunn Landscape Architecture. You can imagine Redick’s kids running between planters while he grills dinner on that fully equipped outdoor kitchen. He once told AD, “For me, it came down to outdoor space. I wanted a real patio, not a Juliet balcony.”
That’s a sentiment every New Yorker understands.
Even Diane Keaton’s former Beverly Hills estate echoed the same shift — from grandeur to grounding. It’s a reminder that luxury today is more about intention than excess.
The Building and Its Brooklyn Backdrop
If you’ve ever walked through Dumbo, you know the kind of energy this neighborhood has. Converted warehouses, riverfront parks, cobblestone streets — and a constant hum of creative professionals and tech folks.
Redick’s building fits right into that narrative: a seven-story ODA-designed conversion with seventy-five residences and amenities that read like a boutique hotel brochure — concierge service, yoga studio, landscaped courtyard, and a rooftop terrace that frames both bridges.
Why does this matter to you as a reader or potential buyer? Because location isn’t just geography; it’s lifestyle insulation. Properties like this aren’t simply about price per square foot — they hold cultural value. You’re buying into a slice of Brooklyn’s evolution, not just a view of Manhattan.
Like Genevieve Gorder’s Manhattan duplex, Redick’s penthouse tells a story about emotional architecture — spaces built for life chapters, not just addresses.
The Market Story Behind the Relist
Let’s talk numbers, because that’s where the real lesson hides.
Brooklyn’s luxury segment has cooled slightly since its 2021 peak. Average prices in Dumbo and Brooklyn Heights have softened by around 8–12 percent, depending on which data set you follow. The $6.2 million relist puts Redick’s penthouse back near its original 2017 purchase price — that alone tells you this isn’t about profit-chasing.
In my view, this is a strategic reset. You relist to refresh visibility and reposition for serious buyers — not tire-kickers who just want a tour of a celebrity home. Agents use relists like a clean slate: new date stamp, renewed energy, new audience. For Redick, it’s also practical. Coaching in Los Angeles full-time while holding a Brooklyn family home doesn’t make long-term sense.
And here’s a wider pattern: other athlete sellers have done the same — Carmelo Anthony’s Chelsea condo, Blake Griffin’s Tribeca place. The post-pandemic correction hit everyone, even celebrities with prime addresses.
By the way, I share short market updates and celebrity home insights on a WhatsApp real-estate tracker I follow — it’s where I spot trends like this weeks before they hit headlines.
Why Redick’s Relist Feels Personal?
I don’t think this listing is only about numbers. Read between the lines and it feels more like a lifestyle pivot. Redick’s journey — Duke star to NBA vet to podcast host to Lakers head coach — has been built on intentional moves.
Selling a home like this signals another one. You can almost see the trade-off: less time in New York, more focus on coaching and family stability on the West Coast.
There’s also an emotional undertone in how the apartment was built. Every archway, every brass hinge feels designed for permanence. So putting it back on the market isn’t casual — it’s a statement about where his next chapter belongs.
And if you’ve ever had to let go of a place that defined a period of your life, you’ll get that mix of pride and nostalgia this sale represents.
It’s a similar story to what we saw with Riki Lindhome’s Los Angeles retreat — design-led homes that reflect lifestyle transitions more than just investment timing.
Why This Relist Says More Than It Seems?
When you strip away the celebrity angle, what’s left here is a quiet indicator of where the high-end Brooklyn market stands right now. Redick’s relist isn’t a random move — it’s part of a broader correction. The pandemic spike inflated luxury listings, but 2024–2025 has forced sellers, even the well-known ones, to rethink what “premium” actually means.
If you’ve followed New York real estate over the past few years, you’ve seen the same rhythm: homes that flew off the market in weeks back in 2021 are now sitting longer, even when they’re architecturally special. Redick’s $6.2 million ask lands right in that zone — fair, realistic, and aligned with a more mature market cycle. To me, that’s smart positioning, not surrender.
There’s also a cultural signal here. The era of “athlete buys massive penthouse for the flex” is fading. The new narrative is about thoughtful design and long-term value — homes that feel like sanctuaries, not trophies. Redick’s penthouse represents that shift perfectly: elegant, family-centered, intentional.
And if you’re someone watching the luxury real-estate space, this is where you pause and think — what does value look like now? Maybe it’s not about square footage or price per foot anymore. Maybe it’s about craftsmanship, privacy, and balance.
So I’ll leave you with this: if you were in Redick’s shoes — moving across coasts, managing a high-pressure career, balancing family and comfort — would you sell a home like this or hold it as an anchor to your old life? That’s the real question behind this relist.
If you enjoy following how celebrity homes evolve in value and design, then you can also explore our Real Estate & Homeownership section for fresh market moves and design shifts shaping high-end living..
Disclaimer: All property details are based on publicly available records and media reports. Prices and availability may change without notice. This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial or real-estate advice.
