Ring vs. SimpliSafe: The Ultimate Home Security Showdown – Best Choice for Your Needs
This post may contain affiliate links. For more details, please read our disclaimer
Are you choosing the right home security system?
With so many security options available in the market, how do you know which one truly protects your home? Do you need a system with professional monitoring, or is a DIY setup enough? and most importantly—how do Ring and SimpliSafe compare when it comes to reliability, features, and cost?
Both systems are the main names in home security, but they supply different needs in home security. In this article, we’ll break down their strengths, weaknesses, and key differences you won’t find in basic reviews. By the end of the article, you’ll know exactly which one suits your home and lifestyle best.
So, let’s get started!
Let me quickly break down a short comparison for you, and then we’ll dive into which one—Ring or SimpliSafe—is the perfect fit for you!
Ring vs. SimpliSafe
| Feature | Ring | SimpliSafe |
| Installation | DIY or Professional ($99) | DIY (Free) or Professional ($99) |
| Equipment Cost | Starts at $199 | Starts at $250 |
| Monitoring | Self-monitoring (Free) or $20–$24.99/month for professional monitoring | Self-monitoring (Free) or $29.99/month for professional monitoring |
| Contract | No contract required | No contract required |
| Smart Home Compatibility | Alexa, Google Assistant, Z-Wave | Alexa, Google Assistant |
| Mobile App | Yes (Live view, notifications, remote control) | Yes (Live view, notifications, remote control) |
| Camera Options | Indoor, Outdoor, Doorbell, Floodlight Cameras | Indoor, Outdoor, Doorbell Cameras |
| Battery Backup | Yes (In some models) | Yes (Up to 24 hours) |
| Cellular Backup | Available with paid plan | Available with paid plan |
| Warranty | 1-Year Warranty | 1-Year Warranty |
Which One Should You Choose?
After a deep comparison, SimpliSafe stands out as the best choice for serious home security, while Ring is perfect for those who want smart features at a lower cost.
- Go for SimpliSafe if you need top-notch professional monitoring, faster emergency response, and a rock-solid security system. It’s ideal for those who put safety above all else.
- Pick Ring if you want an affordable, DIY-friendly system with excellent smart home compatibility. It’s the better option if you already use Alexa or other smart devices.
Our Final Take
If your first priority is strong security and reliable protection, SimpliSafe is the clear winner. But if you’re looking for a budget-friendly, customizable system with smart home perks, Ring is the way to go.
No matter which one you choose, both systems offer peace of mind and better home protection—it all comes down to what matters most to you!
Installation & Ease of Use: Which One is Simpler?
One of the biggest concerns when choosing a home security system is how easy it is to install and use. Both Ring and SimpliSafe offer DIY installation, but they have some key differences in setup, ease of use, and customization. Let’s break it down.
1. DIY Setup vs. Professional Installation
Both Ring and SimpliSafe are designed for easy DIY installation, meaning you don’t need to hire a professional unless you prefer to. However, professional installation is available for an extra cost.
Ring Installation:
- Completely DIY-friendly with step-by-step guides.
- Most devices come with adhesive backing or mounting brackets.
- Professional installation available for $99.
SimpliSafe Installation:
- Also DIY, with easy stick-on sensors and a guided setup.
- No drilling or wiring needed for most devices.
- Professional installation available for $99.
2. Installation Difficulty & Tools Required
Ring:
- Difficulty: Easy to moderate (depending on the device).
- Tools Needed: Basic screwdriver (for mounting cameras or doorbells).
- Setup Time: 15-30 minutes for a basic system.
SimpliSafe:
- Difficulty: Very easy (everything is pre-configured).
- Tools Needed: None for most devices (stick-on installation).
- Setup Time: 10-20 minutes for a complete system.
Winner: SimpliSafe is slightly easier, especially for beginners, as its sensors come pre-configured and ready to use.
3. User Experience: App Usability & Customization
Both Ring and SimpliSafe have smartphone apps for easy system control. Let’s compare:
Winner: Ring is better for smart home users, while SimpliSafe is easier for beginners.
| Feature | Ring App | SimpliSafe App |
| Live View | Yes (Cameras/Doorbells) | Yes (Cameras) |
| Instant Alerts | Yes | Yes |
| Smart Home Integration | Works with Alexa, Google Assistant, & Z-Wave | Works with Alexa & Google Assistant |
| Custom Modes (Away, Home, Off) | Yes | Yes |
| Ease of Use | ⭐⭐⭐⭐☆ (Some advanced settings) | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (Very simple interface) |
Security & Privacy Concerns: How Safe Is Your Data?
1. How Ring & SimpliSafe Handle User Data
These two companies collect and store a lot of information, such as:
- Personal Information: Nam, e-mail, and phone.
- Device Data: Security settings, stored recordings (for users of the company-provided cloud services).
- Location Data: Home addresses and event logs.
Ring’s Approach:
- AWS cloud servers record video footage (optionally encrypt with end-to-end encryption).
- Shares user data with Amazon and third-party analytics services to improve their products.
- Offers optional video encryption & privacy settings for more security.
SimpliSafe’s Approach:
- User data is stored only for security monitoring; there is no third-party tracking.
- Footage is stored on encrypted SimpliSafe servers (if you go for a camera plan)
- No direct integration with big tech companies (Amazon, Google), thus she lessens the risk of external monitoring.
Winner: SimpliSafe is more privacy-friendly because it collects less data and doesn’t rely on third-party analytics as much as Ring.
Ring’s Troubling Security Past: More Than Just a Few Glitches
If you are considering Ring for your home security, it’s important to take a closer look at its past security incidents. These were not just minor glitches—these events raised serious concerns about Ring’s ability to protect user data and privacy.
1. 2019: Hackers Took Over Ring Cameras, Turning Security into a Nightmare
In 2019, multiple disturbing cases emerged where hackers gained access to Ring cameras—and this wasn’t an isolated issue. It became a pattern, affecting several users across the country.
- In one particularly alarming case, a hacker took control of a Ring camera inside a home in Mississippi and began speaking to an eight-year-old girl in her bedroom. The hacker said, “Hello there… I’m Santa Claus. Don’t you want to be my best friend?”
- In another case, a couple reported that their Ring camera in the bedroom was hijacked, and the hacker started yelling at them through the speaker.
The major issue? Users had no idea their accounts were vulnerable. Ring was not enforcing two-factor authentication (2FA) at the time, which meant hackers could easily take over cameras just by guessing weak passwords.
After these incidents received massive media attention, Ring was forced to introduce security updates. But by then, the damage had been done.
2. 2020: Ring Secretly Shared User Data with Third-Party Trackers
An investigation by the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) revealed that Ring’s mobile app had hidden third-party trackers that collected and shared user data with companies like Facebook and Google—without user consent. Ring never explicitly informed users about this, raising serious privacy concerns.
3. 2021: FTC Fines Ring for Security & Privacy Violations
The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) found that Ring employees and third-party contractors had unrestricted access to users’ private videos. Additionally, Ring failed to implement proper safeguards, allowing hackers to take control of cameras. The company was fined and forced to improve security measures.
SimpliSafe Security Issues:
1. 2019: Key Fob Vulnerability
- A security researcher discovered that SimpliSafe’s wireless key fob system was vulnerable to code spoofing, meaning attackers could potentially disarm the system by intercepting and replaying signals.
- Fix: SimpliSafe quickly addressed this issue by rolling out a firmware update to improve encryption and security measures.
2. No Major Privacy Scandals or Government Fines
- Unlike Ring, SimpliSafe has not been involved in any major user privacy scandals, data-sharing controversies, or FTC fines.
- The company maintains a relatively strong track record when it comes to user privacy and data security.
Winner: SimpliSafe has had fewer security controversies, while Ring has a history of privacy concerns.
3. Steps Taken to Improve Privacy
Both companies have made efforts to strengthen security after facing public scrutiny.
Ring’s Improvements:
- Two-Factor Authentication (2FA): Now mandatory for all users, reducing the risk of unauthorized logins.
- End-to-End Encryption (E2EE): Added for video storage to ensure only authorized users can access footage.
- Privacy Control Center: A new app feature that lets users adjust data-sharing settings for better control.
SimpliSafe’s Improvements:
- Encrypted Communication: Improved encryption between sensors and the base station to prevent signal spoofing.
- Stronger Authentication: Enhanced security measures to prevent unauthorized access.
- No Third-Party Data Sharing: Unlike Ring, SimpliSafe does not share user data with third parties, except for essential monitoring services.
Winner: SimpliSafe
SimpliSafe still has a better reputation for privacy. While Ring has made significant improvements, it continues to collect more user data, keeping privacy concerns alive.
Still need help choosing? Feel free to reach out me!
Future-Proofing & Updates: Who’s Better?
Ring:
- Frequent firmware & app updates.
- Added end-to-end encryption, better motion detection, and Alexa integration in the last 2 years.
- Backed by Amazon, ensuring long-term development but with ongoing privacy concerns.
SimpliSafe:
- Regular security-focused updates (better encryption, authentication, and emergency response).
- Improved sensor encryption & faster emergency dispatch in recent years.
- Strong long-term reliability as a dedicated security company.
Winner: Depends on You
- Want smart home features & frequent updates? → Ring
- Want strong security & privacy-focused updates? → SimpliSafe
Which System is Best for You?
Instead of a one-size-fits-all approach, here’s a breakdown based on different needs:
1. Best for Renters → SimpliSafe
- No permanent installation, easy to set up and move.
- No contracts, so you can cancel anytime.
2. Best for Homeowners → SimpliSafe
- Strong security, expandable system with professional monitoring.
- Better reliability for long-term home protection.
3. Best for Privacy-Conscious Users → SimpliSafe
- No third-party data sharing.
- Stronger encryption and better security track record.
4. Best for Budget Buyers → Ring
- Affordable pricing with flexible monitoring options.
- No contracts required, making it cost-effective.
5. Best for Tech-Savvy Users → Ring
- Works seamlessly with Alexa, smart locks, and other devices.
- Frequent software updates with new smart features.
Best Ring & SimpliSafe Products for Home Security
1. Best Ring Products
1. Ring Video Doorbell Pro 2 (Best for Smart Security & Video Monitoring)
If you want top-tier video quality and smart detection features, this is the best Ring doorbell available.
- 3D Motion Detection & Bird’s Eye View – Get precise motion alerts and track movement around your home.
- 1536p HD+ Video with HDR – Crystal-clear visuals, even in low light.
- Two-Way Talk & Quick Replies – Speak to visitors from anywhere or use preset responses.
- Works with Alexa – View live footage on Echo devices & Fire TV.
- Wired Connection – More reliable than battery-powered options.
Check Ring Video Doorbell Pro 2 on Amazon
2. Ring Alarm Pro Security Kit (Best for Full Home Security & DIY Setup)
This is an all-in-one home security system that includes everything you need for smart protection.
- Base Station with Built-in Eero WiFi 6 Router – Ensures stable connection & extra security.
- 8-Piece Kit – Includes a keypad, motion detectors, contact sensors, and range extender.
- Works with Alexa & Ring Cameras – Get instant alerts & automate your security.
- DIY Installation – No professional setup required.
Check Ring Alarm Pro Security Kit on Amazon
2. Best SimpliSafe Products
1. SimpliSafe 10-Piece Security System (Best for Comprehensive Protection & Privacy)
For a reliable, contract-free security system, this is one of SimpliSafe’s most trusted options.
- Includes 10 Components – Base station, keypad, key fob, motion sensor, entry sensors, siren, glassbreak sensor, and wired indoor camera.
- 24/7 Professional Monitoring Available – Fast emergency response if needed.
- No Contracts – Unlike Ring, you don’t need a monthly subscription.
- Smart Alerts & Mobile Control – Manage everything from the SimpliSafe app.
- Privacy-Focused – No unnecessary data tracking.
Check SimpliSafe 10-Piece System on Amazon
Conclusion
Both Ring and SimpliSafe are great options, but the best choice depends on your needs:
- Pick SimpliSafe for stronger security, better privacy, and reliable professional monitoring.
- Pick Ring for affordable pricing, smart home features, and Alexa integration.
Overall, SimpliSafe is better for security, while Ring is ideal for smart home users.
Still unsure? Feel free to reach out!
