Two Men Found Guilty in Home Invasion Targeting Staten Island Family

I live in Staten Island, and like a lot of people here, I’ve always felt our neighborhoods were quiet, safe, close-knit. That’s why this story hit different.

Two men were just convicted for forcing their way into a family’s home in Arrochar—a peaceful area not known for crime. They didn’t just break in. According to prosecutors, they zip-tied the parents, threatened their lives, and searched the home while their young daughter hid in the bathroom, terrified.

This wasn’t random. The attackers had planned it. They showed up with gloves and masks, looking for cash. It could’ve ended even worse—but thankfully, the family survived, and justice caught up.

I’ll break down what happened, what the court decided, and more importantly, what it means for you and your family. Because if this can happen in Arrochar, it can happen anywhere.

What Really Happened That Night in Staten Island?

It was just an ordinary evening in a quiet Staten Island neighborhood—until it wasn’t.

According to SILive, two men—Anthony Thomas and Uthman Saddiq—forced their way into a family’s home in Arrochar. They weren’t just burglars—they came masked, gloved, and fully prepared.

Inside, they zip-tied the mother and father at gunpoint. Their daughter was home too. She managed to lock herself in the bathroom and call 911. Just try to imagine what that moment felt like for her.

The attackers searched the house for cash, threatening the family. Prosecutors said this wasn’t random—they targeted the victims on purpose.

And that’s what hit me. If something this organized and deliberate can happen here, then we’ve got to stop thinking it’s always “someone else’s neighborhood.”

Who These Men Were—and What the Court Decided?

I always ask: “Did justice actually happen?” In this case, yeah—it did.

Anthony Thomas, 31, and Uthman Saddiq, 26, were both arrested not long after the incident. Prosecutors built a solid case, backed by surveillance, statements, and physical evidence. There was no question—they did it.

Last week, both men were convicted of first-degree burglary and robbery. Each is facing six years behind bars as part of a plea deal. Sentencing is scheduled for July 29.

Now, you might be thinking—only six years? For a crime like this?

I had the same question. The truth is, under New York law, plea deals often mean lighter sentences. But at least they’re off the streets. And this conviction sends a message: you don’t terrorize families and walk away free.

In some states, similar crimes have led to very different outcomes — like this violent home invasion in Missaukee County that ended in a harsher charge.

Staten Island Isn’t Supposed to Be Like This… Right?

Look, I’ve lived here most of my life. Staten Island’s always been that borough where families go to feel a little more safe, a little more grounded.

That’s why this story shook so many of us.

Arrochar isn’t the South Bronx. It’s not Brownsville. It’s a quiet, residential pocket. People know their neighbors. Kids ride bikes outside. But that illusion of safety? It cracked open the second armed men walked through that family’s front door.

It’s not about creating panic—it’s about getting real. Complacency is what criminals count on. It’s time we stop assuming “it won’t happen here.”

Similar bold break-ins have happened elsewhere too — like this armed robbery in Florence, where suspects are still on the run.

Is Crime Getting Worse in Staten Island?

Short answer? Not exactly. But the kind of crime is changing—and that’s something you and I need to pay attention to.

NYPD stats show Staten Island still has the lowest crime rate among the five boroughs. But home invasions like this? They’ve been creeping up.

Just last December, police arrested two men after a violent home invasion in Manor Heights. In that case, the residents were assaulted. In another case from 2022, someone was shot during a break-in in Arden Heights.

These aren’t petty thefts or car break-ins. These are targeted, aggressive crimes—and they’re different.

If you’re thinking, “This sounds like it’s becoming a pattern,” you’re not wrong. It’s not daily news—but it’s also not once-in-a-decade anymore.

And with each new incident, that feeling of safety slips a little further away.

Lately, I’ve seen more people sharing quick safety updates and local alerts through WhatsApp broadcast lists — sometimes that’s the first place I hear about neighborhood incidents.

What You Can Do Right Now to Protect Your Home?

When something like this happens close to home, the first instinct is fear. The second should be action.

I’ve spent the last few years researching personal safety and speaking with NYPD officers for other stories. Here’s what I always hear: most homes are easier to break into than we’d like to believe.

You don’t need a fortress. But you do need to stop relying on luck.

Start with the basics:

• Reinforce your front and back doors (deadbolts, strike plates, smart locks)
• Install motion-activated lights
• Use security cameras—even simple doorbell ones
• Don’t advertise vacations on social media
• Get to know your neighbors

Most break-ins happen when no one’s home. But in Arrochar, that wasn’t the case. That’s why personal alarms, home panic buttons, and even safe rooms are becoming more common in upper-middle-class homes—because “quiet neighborhood” doesn’t mean “risk-free.”

If this story made you pause, don’t sit on it. Do one small thing today to tighten your home’s security.

I’d love to hear how you’re handling home safety in your area. Have you made any changes recently? Drop your thoughts in the comments — I read every one.

What New York Law Says About Home Invasions?

A lot of readers I talk to are surprised to learn how New York classifies crimes like this.

Technically, what happened in Arrochar wasn’t labeled as “home invasion” in legal terms—it was prosecuted as first-degree burglary and robbery. Why? Because under New York Penal Law, there’s no specific statute called “home invasion.” Instead, it’s defined by what the intruders do once inside.

In this case:

• The men entered unlawfully
• They were armed
• They restrained and threatened the residents
• And the crime was targeted, not random

All that adds up to one of the most serious types of burglary charges in the state.

But here’s what caught my attention: even with all that, they’re getting six years.

Now, I’m not here to debate sentencing laws—but I do think we need to stay informed. Because if this happened to your family, you’d want to know exactly what the law does (and doesn’t) protect.

Sadly, it’s not just here — homes across the country, like this one in Southwest Atlanta, are being targeted in equally brazen ways.

Final Thoughts

When I first read about this home invasion, my gut reaction wasn’t shock—it was “again?”

Because this isn’t isolated anymore. It’s a pattern. And patterns mean we have to pay attention.

I took this story personally. Maybe because I grew up in neighborhoods just like Arrochar. Maybe because I know too many people who still believe, “That would never happen here.”

But you and I both know the truth now.

So here’s my ask: don’t move on from this like it’s just another news headline. Talk about it with your family. Make one small change to your home’s safety plan. And if you’re part of a local group—bring this up.

Because the families who got tied up that night? They weren’t doing anything wrong. They were just home.

And next time, it could be someone you know.

What’s one safety change you’ve been putting off? And what’s stopping you from doing it today?

If you’re following local crime updates, you’ll find more in our safety and neighborhood alerts section. Visit our website Build Like New.

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and is not intended as legal advice. For specific legal concerns, please consult a qualified attorney. All facts are based on publicly available sources at the time of writing.