The $4.5 Million Tennessee Home That Went On and Off Market Three Times During a Nasty Divorce

When Christina Haack listed her Tennessee farmhouse for $4.5 million in October 2024, her estranged husband Josh Hall was still living inside it.

She posted about it on Instagram the same day. “I guess Leiper’s Fork is gonna have to come off the bio soon,” she wrote, pointing directly at the Tennessee location Josh had added to his profile after moving in. That was the tone from day one.

What followed was four months of court orders, delistings, relistings, and public shade. Josh used every legal tool he had. And when the dust settled, the farmhouse stayed with her. Now it is back on the market.

The House He Did Not Buy

Christina purchased Parker Branch in February 2021 for $2.5 million, months before she even met Josh Hall.

The property sits on nearly 24 acres in Leiper’s Fork, Franklin, Tennessee. 6 bedrooms, 6 bathrooms, 5,200 square feet.

A wood-burning fireplace, open kitchen, wood floors, pool, hot tub, barn, and a primary suite with his-and-hers closets. She renovated it extensively after buying it, and the result shows.

She filed it as Separate Property in her July 2024 divorce petition. That detail matters more than most coverage acknowledges.

The Timeline Nobody Tells in Full

Josh filed for divorce in July 2024, citing irreconcilable differences. He also requested monthly spousal support, despite no prenuptial agreement between them.

A temporary court order in September gave Josh use of the farmhouse while Christina kept their $12 million Newport Beach home. Six weeks later, she listed the farmhouse anyway.

Josh filed an emergency order to block the sale on October 10. His argument: mortgage payments made during their marriage gave him an “appreciation interest” in the property.

“A premature sale may result in prejudice to me as property values continue to rise in Tennessee,” he wrote in court documents. A judge temporarily agreed. The listing came down October 25.

Christina relisted at the same $4.5 million on December 3 with agent Kelly Dougherty.

In January 2025, a court ordered her to set aside $150,000 from any sale proceeds for Josh. Then on February 11, the listing disappeared again after Josh’s legal team filed new financial documents.

Per Realtor.com’s coverage of the listing, the property had become one of the more tangled celebrity divorce real estate battles in recent memory. Four months. Two listings. Two delistings. Zero buyers.

Why the Farmhouse Was Hard to Move Anyway

Here is the part most articles skip.

Luxury properties in Franklin, TN were not moving quickly during this period. Per Redfin data, homes in Franklin were averaging 68 days on the market by early 2025, up from 52 days the year before. At the $4 million-plus price point, that number only grows.

Buyers in that range are not paying for celebrity adjacency. They want clean paperwork, clear ownership, and pricing that holds up. A home tangled in active court filings adds real hesitation for any serious buyer.

This pattern keeps showing up across high-profile listings. Chris Evans relisted his Hollywood Hills home at $6.4 million after it sat unsold for over a year, another reminder that a recognizable name on a listing cannot override a market that has already made up its mind on pricing and clarity.

There is a WhatsApp channel that covers stories like this as they happen, before the wider news cycle catches up. Worth having in your feed if you follow luxury real estate closely.

Why This Matters

This is not just a messy divorce story. It is also not over yet.

Parker Branch is back on the market right now as a “coming soon” listing at $4.5 million, with the same agent, Kelly Dougherty of Onward Real Estate. Nearly a year after the divorce was finalized, Christina is ready to sell.

The settlement itself was complicated. In August 2025, both parties waived spousal support. Christina paid Josh $300,000 as an equalization payment, kept the farmhouse, and kept the Newport Beach mansion. Josh kept his own property in Thompson’s Station, TN.

But Christina’s own words told a different story than the official statement. Speaking on SiriusXM’s Jeff Lewis Live, she said: “Look, it’s not great, but I guess it’s done.”

Her co-host summed it up: if both parties feel equally unhappy, the negotiation probably landed in the right place.

The broader pattern in celebrity real estate is consistent. Per Redfin’s Franklin, TN housing market data, Franklin home prices were up 7.7% year over year by mid-2025, with a median sale price of $850,000.

For acreage-heavy properties above $4 million, the upside is real, but the buyer pool is narrow and patient.

The same calculus plays out elsewhere.

Diane Keaton’s Beverly Hills home, bought from Madonna for $8 million, sat unsold at $20 million for months, while Jaylen Brown listed two Boston units together for nearly $5 million and had buyers circling almost immediately.

Clean deal, right price, right market. That is what moves property.

Christina bought this farmhouse for $2.5 million. Poured money and attention into it. Fought to keep it through a year of litigation. And is now trying to sell it anyway.

The “last laugh” was keeping it. What happens next is the open question.

Key Takeaways

• Christina bought Parker Branch in February 2021 for $2.5 million, before meeting Josh Hall
• She listed it at $4.5 million in October 2024 while Josh was still living there under a court agreement
• Josh filed an emergency order to block the sale, citing mortgage paydown interest during the marriage
• The listing was pulled twice: October 25, 2024 and February 11, 2025
• A court ordered $150,000 set aside from any sale proceeds for Josh in January 2025
• The August 2025 settlement gave Christina the farmhouse outright, with a $300,000 equalization payment to Josh
• No spousal support was awarded to either party
• The farmhouse is now back on the market as a “coming soon” listing at $4.5 million
• “Christina in the Country” was cancelled after Season 2 and will not return

Was Josh Hall’s legal move a legitimate claim or a delay tactic on the way out? And do you think the farmhouse sells this time around? Drop your take in the comments.

Wrapping Up

This was never really about the farmhouse alone. It was about leverage, timing, and who was willing to hold their ground the longest.

Christina listed a property she owned before the marriage, held it through a year of legal back-and-forth, paid less than Josh originally demanded, and kept both properties. Now she is selling on her own terms.

If stories like this are your thing, Build Like New covers celebrity real estate, luxury market moves, and the real stories behind big transactions regularly. Worth bookmarking if you want more than just the headline.

For more as it happens, follow Build Like New on X (Twitter) and join the conversation on the Facebook community. That is where these stories get discussed as they break.

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only. All details are based on publicly available reports and court documents at the time of publication.