This Oregon Home Had a Vault. Burglars Broke In Anyway and Took Everything Inside

The vault was supposed to be the safe option. It was not.

A home in Bandon, Coos County, Oregon held a private vault with roughly $1 million in cash, gold, silver coins, and a large firearms collection. Four men found it anyway. Two burglaries. Four days apart. Same vault.

And it all started with one man convincing another that the homeowner deserved it.

The Home and the Man Who Owned It

The property belonged to Brian Tenney, former owner of the West Coast Game Park Safari, a roadside zoo that Oregon State Police raided and shut down in May 2025 after removing more than 300 animals.

Tenney pleaded guilty in April 2026 to 47 counts including animal neglect, weapons charges, racketeering, and drug offenses. His sentencing is set for July 20, 2026.

Inside his residence was a vault loaded with cash, gold, silver coins, and dozens of firearms. The kind of collection that puts a target on a door once the wrong person finds out.

Two Break-Ins, Four Days Apart

On December 19, 2023, Matthew Knapp (48), Daniel Knapp (58), and William Travis Cutlip (41) broke in and walked out with approximately $1 million in cash, gold, silver coins, and at least one firearm.

Court documents say Matthew Knapp recruited Cutlip by telling him the homeowner was “a bad person who had obtained and hidden money through serious wrongdoing.”

Four days later, Cutlip told Kyle Vanalstine (31) about the burglary. Vanalstine went back himself and stole around 40 firearms. Cutlip then bought the guns from him and paid him separately for his silence.

Some of those firearms were later found in California.

On January 5, 2024, Vanalstine was pulled over in Curry County. Officers found more than one kilogram of methamphetamine, scales, and a loaded pistol. A search of his property turned up a stolen silencer and assault rifles.

Full sentencing details were reported by the Statesman Journal.

When a Burglary Becomes a Federal Case

Once stolen guns crossed into California, this became a federal firearms trafficking investigation. ATF, FBI, the South Coos Interagency Narcotics Team, Oregon State Police, and five additional agencies joined in. Nine agencies. One residential vault.

This pattern of targeted break-ins, where the crew knows exactly what is inside, keeps showing up. The Woodland Hills burglars who hit a home and vanished before police arrived operated the same way. These are not impulse crimes.

If you follow crime and property stories, channel on WhatsApp covers cases like this as they develop. Worth keeping in your feed.

Why This Matters

This Oregon home burglary did not end the way most do. According to Forbes home burglary data, 87% of burglary victims never see an arrest. This case is the exception, and it still took over two years and nearly a dozen agencies.

The FBI puts the average burglary loss at around $2,661. The Bandon vault held roughly 375 times that.

And when stolen weapons move across state lines, the danger spreads well beyond the original crime, as the San Fernando Valley homeowners who caught burglars cutting their flood lights on camera and the armed robbery at a Morton Grove hotel both make clear.

Vanalstine received 77 months in federal prison. Cutlip got 24 months, with the court factoring in his background as a decorated veteran dealing with PTSD and addiction.

Daniel Knapp received 24 months. Matthew Knapp received five years of probation in state court and was ordered to pay over $600,000 in restitution.

The federal case closed in July 2026, two and a half years after the vault was first broken into.

Key Takeaways

• Brian Tenney, former West Coast Game Park Safari owner, owned the burglarized home
• Three men stole roughly $1 million in cash, gold, and silver on December 19, 2023
• Matthew Knapp recruited Cutlip using a “he deserved it” justification
• Vanalstine returned four days later and stole around 40 additional firearms
• Cutlip bought the guns and paid Vanalstine separately for his silence
• Several firearms were later recovered in California
• Sentences ranged from five years probation to 77 months in federal prison
• Matthew Knapp was ordered to pay over $600,000 in restitution

A million-dollar vault, four men, and a justification that did not hold up in court. Do you think the “he deserved it” angle changes how you see this case, or does the method speak for itself? Drop your take in the comments.

Wrapping Up

One man told another the homeowner deserved it. Four federal cases later, the courts disagreed.

If this kind of story is your thing, Build Like New covers crime, real estate, and the human side of big stories regularly. Worth bookmarking.

Follow Build Like New on X (Twitter) and join the Facebook community for stories like this as they break.

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only. All details are based on publicly available reports and federal court documents at the time of publication.