A 1920s Hollywood Hills Villa Where Old Hollywood Magic Actually Happened Is Now Up for Sale at 2.3 Million

Some homes hold history in their walls. This one holds a love story.

A 1923 Spanish Revival villa in the heart of Los Angeles’s Whitley Heights has just listed for $2.295 million. The headline alone would be enough for most real estate articles. But the story behind why this home exists is what makes it something else entirely.

Rudolph Valentino reportedly commissioned it for Pola Negri.

A House Born From One of Hollywood’s Most Iconic Romances

Whitley Heights was not just any neighborhood. Developed in the early 1900s by H.J. Whitley, it was designed as a hillside Mediterranean village overlooking the city.

Charlie Chaplin lived here. So did Bette Davis and Gloria Swanson. It was the first real celebrity enclave in Los Angeles, built during the exact years that Hollywood was inventing itself.

Into this neighborhood, Valentino reportedly built this white-stucco, red-tiled villa for Negri, the Polish-born silent film star who became one of Hollywood’s original femme fatales.

Their romance was brief, magnetic, and completely public. They met at a Marion Davies costume party in 1925. They became lovers after their second meeting and remained so for a year, until his death.

Valentino died in August 1926. At his funeral, Negri sent $2,000 worth of blood-red roses with “Pola” spelled out in white blossoms in the middle.

The house outlasted all of it.

What the Property Actually Looks Like Today

The current sellers, James Roncal and Stuart Marks, bought the home in April 2016 for $1.05 million. They did not gut it. They restored it.

The original hardwood floors are still there. So are the wrought ironwork, the swing windows, and a wood-burning fireplace in the primary bedroom with its original Arts and Crafts-style Batchelder tiles.

They redid the kitchen with walnut cabinetry, updated two bathrooms, and restored three fireplaces, all while keeping the period character intact.

The main house has 2 bedrooms. A detached 1930 casita adds a third bedroom, bathroom, its own living room, kitchen, dining area, and patio. Total living space across both structures is 2,500 square feet.

The grounds were redesigned by LA-based landscape studio Terremoto, adding cypress, citrus, and philodendron alongside a pergola-covered dining area with Moroccan tile floors and a deck overlooking the Whitley Heights hills.

The full listing details are covered in the Mansion Global report for anyone wanting to dig into the specs.

Why Historic LA Homes Like This One Are Moving Fast Right Now

Most coverage of this listing will stop at the romance angle. What they skip is the market context that makes this listing genuinely interesting beyond the story.

Whitley Heights today holds National Register of Historic Places designation and a Historic Preservation Overlay Zone status, making it one of LA’s most architecturally intact neighborhoods. That protection matters for buyers.

What is preserved cannot be demolished or dramatically altered. The character is locked in by law.

Spanish Revival homes in protected historic neighborhoods across LA are averaging 30 to 40 days on market, significantly faster than the citywide 61-day average. Buyers are not being sentimental. They are being strategic.

Properties like this attract design-conscious buyers who value period details: original tile work, arched doorways, and mature landscaping that took decades to establish. This property has all three.

This same pattern of buyers paying for provenance and story has been showing up consistently. Jake Paul dropping $39 million on a 6,000-acre Georgia ranch made headlines for the price, but the land’s history and scale were a big part of what moved that deal.

If you follow luxury real estate moves like this as they happen, there is a WhatsApp channel that covers these stories in real time. Worth checking if you want to catch listings before the news cycle does.

Why This Matters

The numbers give this even more weight.

According to the California Association of Realtors, homes priced at $2 million and above in California saw an 8.4% increase in sales compared to April 2025. Luxury buyers are active.

And in a market where comparably storied properties list far higher, a $2.295 million price on a legally protected, century-old Spanish Revival in a neighborhood of this caliber is genuinely rare.

Historic homes do not always sell easy though. When Dr. Seuss’s Southern California home sold for $9 million, it was the combination of provenance, condition, and the right buyer that made it work.

On the flip side, Hulk Hogan’s Florida mansion sat unsold even after a $2 million price cut, a reminder that a name attached to a property does not guarantee a sale. The story has to land the right way with the right buyer.

A Valentino-commissioned villa in an intact historic district, carefully restored and priced at $2.295 million, makes a strong case for itself.

Key Takeaways

• Built in 1923 in Whitley Heights, one of LA’s first celebrity neighborhoods
• Listed at $2.295 million by sellers James Roncal and Stuart Marks, who bought it for $1.05 million in 2016
• Reportedly commissioned by Rudolph Valentino for silent film star Pola Negri
• 2,500 square feet total, including a detached 1930 casita with its own living room and kitchen
• Original details preserved: hardwood floors, Batchelder tile fireplace, wrought ironwork, swing windows
• Whitley Heights carries National Register of Historic Places designation, protecting the neighborhood’s character
• Homes priced above $2 million in California saw 8.4% sales growth year over year in April 2026

What do you think actually drives the value of a home like this: the architecture, the protected neighborhood, or the century-old love story behind it?

Would knowing Valentino commissioned this property change how you see the asking price? Drop your take in the comments below.

Wrapping Up

Valentino died in 1926. Pola Negri never stopped grieving him publicly. And the house he reportedly built for her has now been standing for over 100 years, through Hollywood’s rise, its reinventions, and everything the city has become since.

That is a long time for walls to hold a story. The next owner gets all of it.

If this kind of story is your thing, Build Like New covers celebrity real estate, luxury market shifts, and the human side of big property moves regularly. Worth bookmarking if you want more than just the headline numbers.

For more stories like this as they break, follow Build Like New on X (Twitter) and join the conversation over on the Facebook community. That is where these get discussed in real time.

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only. All details are based on publicly available reports at the time of publication.