The Hamptons Estate Libbie Mugrabi Won in Her Divorce Just Hit the Market for $25 Million
The house at the center of New York’s most talked-about divorce is officially on the market.
Libbie Mugrabi has listed her Bridgehampton estate for $25 million. The same property that sat at the middle of a years-long legal battle, a $100 million settlement demand, and one of the most dramatic splits Manhattan’s social scene has ever witnessed.
This is not just a real estate story. It never really was.
The House She Fought For
Libbie and David Mugrabi bought this Bridgehampton estate in early 2007 for around $3.8 million, two years into their marriage. No prenuptial agreement. That detail would matter enormously later.
The property spans nearly 7 acres tucked between Sag Harbor and Water Mill, gated and private.
The main home runs about 10,700 square feet across multiple levels, with 6 bedrooms, 7 bathrooms, 5 fireplaces, a movie theater, a climate-controlled wine cellar, and a bubblegum-pink kitchen.
Architect Francis D’Haene reimagined it during the Mugrabis’ tenure as a “living gallery.” A Damien Hirst lime-green heart installation anchors the living room. Two pickleball courts sit on the grounds alongside a pool, spa, and pool house.
It is the kind of home that tells you exactly who lived there.
The Divorce That New York Called Its Nastiest
Proceedings began in mid-2018, triggered by a July dinner party at this very house. Guests ended up in the pool after midnight. Libbie had gone to sleep. She woke up to a situation that confirmed suspicions she had held for some time.
What followed was two years of very public litigation.
No prenup meant everything was on the table: a reported $72 million Manhattan townhouse, a $5 billion art collection including the world’s largest private holding of Andy Warhol works, and a $500,000 Keith Haring sculpture the couple reportedly wrestled over.
New York Post labeled it the city’s nastiest divorce of that circle. Sources told Avenue Magazine that Libbie sought $100 million in the messy multi-year settlement. The deal finalized in December 2020. The Bridgehampton estate went to Libbie.
One More Wrinkle Right Before the Sale
Robb Report covered the listing details but missed something that broke the same week.
Art critic Anthony Haden-Guest filed a lawsuit against Libbie in New York State Supreme Court, claiming 97 of his original cartoons have been hanging inside this Bridgehampton mansion for over 15 years.
He gave Mugrabi the drawings for a planned exhibition at her home. The show never happened. The cartoons stayed. He wants them back.
The house is not just a listing. It is an active scene.
Real estate with a complicated past has a way of holding onto its stories long after the principals move on.
The farmhouse where the FBI arrested Ghislaine Maxwell is now available for rent, and people are still fascinated by what happened inside those walls. Some properties carry weight that no listing description can neutralize.
If you follow stories like this closely, there is a WhatsApp channel that tracks celebrity real estate and luxury market moves as they break. Worth checking if you want to stay ahead of the news cycle.
This kind of complication is not unusual in high-profile sales. Much like this Florida foam dome home that looks like the Death Star and just hit the market, unique properties always carry a backstory that the price tag alone cannot explain.
Why This Matters
The $25 million ask is not a vanity number. Bridgehampton’s market has earned it.
In 2025, the broader Bridgehampton area closed over $1.16 billion in home sales, up 29% from the prior year. Seven transactions exceeded $20 million, tying East Hampton Village for the most in that bracket on the South Fork.
The Hamptons overall hit a record median sale price of $2.34 million in Q4 2025, up 34% year-over-year, driven by Wall Street bonuses and rising tech wealth.
A property bought for $3.8 million in 2007 listing at $25 million in 2026 is not a stretch. It is math.
The listing is held by Deborah Pirro of Daniel Gale Sotheby’s International Realty. Behind every big listing there is always a bigger story.
This one has more than most. Drew Barrymore recently sold her $5 million Westchester mansion with a private gate and 12 acres of seclusion and even that straightforward-seeming transaction had its own quiet weight to it.
Key Takeaways
- Property listed at $25 million in Bridgehampton, New York
- Originally purchased in 2007 for approximately $3.8 million
- 10,700 sq ft, 6 bed, 7 bath, nearly 7 acres, gated compound
- Libbie received the estate as part of her December 2020 divorce settlement
- No prenup existed between Libbie and David Mugrabi
- Mugrabi family holds one of the world’s largest private Warhol collections, 1,000+ works
- Art critic Anthony Haden-Guest filed suit the same week, claiming 97 cartoons are still inside the home
- Bridgehampton market crossed $1.16 billion in sales in 2025, up 29% year-over-year
What do you think should happen to a property once it becomes part of a public legal story? Does the history stay with the house, or does it reset the moment a new buyer signs? Drop your take in the comments below.
Wrapping Up
Libbie Mugrabi walked into this marriage at 21 with no prenup and walked out, after 14 years and two kids, with a Bridgehampton estate, a chunk of one of the world’s most significant art collections, and a story that New York will not forget quickly.
Now she is selling the house. And the market, for once, is actually on her side.
If this kind of story is your thing, Build Like New covers celebrity real estate, luxury market moves, and the human side of big transactions regularly. Worth bookmarking if you want more than just the price tag.
For more stories like this in real time, follow Build Like New on X (Twitter) and join the conversation over on the Facebook community. That is where these stories get discussed as they break.
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only. All details are based on publicly available reports at the time of publication.
